This was our second visit to Mario's and the first visit prompted our second HOWEVER, this will also be our last visti to Mario's. We had reserved a waterfront table and were seated just where we wanted to be. My husband and I ordered mahi mahi and were served promptly--Both dishes were so overcooked and dries out, neither one of us enjoyed our meal. The asparagus was limp and slimy--I do not think the entrees were freshly cooked that evening. No one came to ask us how our meal was, they kind of glanced over and noticed we were not eating. When the waiter came to clear our plates, he asked if there was a problem and we said the fish was dry.--No apologies, nothing--The end of Mario's for us. Too many other stellar restaurants on the island.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.