I ordered the Veal Ossobucco and it was FANTASTIC! If I had the opportunity to go back, I'd definitely order that again. My boyfriend got the fantasia pizza, and unfortunately it was not good.
Gibb's Lighthouse is absolutely beautiful at night. I'd definitely recommend checking it out while you're in Bermuda. We sat inside since there was a private event going on outside. The dining room is quaint and nicely decorated. If we would have had the opportunity I would have sat outside.