We had reservations in advance due to many referrals. Late in the afternoon we decided to opt for a more casual evening and dinner, so we cancelled. As our relaxed last evening in Bermuda progressed, we once again changed our minds! - and checked again to see if we could be accommodated at Waterlot for an 8:30 pm time. To our pleasant surprise, were were welcomed.
Had a wonderful pre-dinner cocktail as we waited to be seated. While the restaurant is formal , we found the waiters easily warmed up and were enthusiastic about giving us good service and helping us with our selections. I am a self professed steak snotb, and found our steak filet mignons were cooked to perfection and so tasty . You HAVE to have the shared side dish: Macaroni and cheese. - Not your ordinary mac and cheese and completely worth every calorie! Even worth skipping dessert for!
As far as desserts go, we should have gone with our waiter's suggestion and had the sticky toffee. We went with the cheesecake, that was just average. They happily provided a complimentary scoop of ice cream upon my husband's request - so not all was lost on dessert!
We enjoyed meeting Eduardo who came around to see how we were enjoying ourselves. We learned that he is formerly from Cuba and Montreal and he was very gracious and charming!
Great evening. So glad we followed through. Highly recommend for a special and memorable meal and evening.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.