The only reason I can think as to why this resort does not rate much higher than it does is that it has a wide range of accommodation, some of which is set back some way from the beach, and perhaps that rates less well? The resort is almost split in two with reception and facilities in the middle, and the more expensive accommodation layered down to the beach with hillside cottages above reception. A fair mention is made of stairs and there are maybe 50 or so between reception and the beach, but we never found it an issue.
We had a beachfront cottage and a delux cottage both of which were excellent. There appeared to be little difference between them, other than the position, but the beachfront cottage had a bath in addition to the shower, and also had a Nepresso machine. The cottages are beautifully set in natural bush, have been recently renovated and whilst not up to the very high standard set by say Andara or The Shore, have a great deal of charm and are very much in keeping with the setting I was surprised to see that most of the cottages in the delux and superior category seemed to have some form of sea views, and often very good views. The beachfront cottages are of course well positioned but to be honest we spent so much time on the beach that it hardly mattered! All the lower cottages are close to the sea and you hear the sea at night!
The beach is the best we have seen in Phuket, about 300m long and given its geography shared only by The Surin and Amanpuri. There is no public access other than by boat or a tough climb over rocks. Effectively this is a private beach and we hardly saw more than 10-20 people in the water across the whole beach! This is not a beach with hundreds of umbrellas. The water is beautifully clear and clean. Sure, a few vendors who were so nice and graciously accepted every rejection; we were very happy to support them where we could. The breakfasts were excellent and the other meals we had were very good but at "resort" prices. We walked into Surin Beach most evenings for drinks and dinner, a 10-15 minute walk. One small criticism is that I think the hotel could run a shuttle in the evenings, people are going to walk to town anyway so why not add a service? We also used the spa and had a great experience. Staff were fantastic, particularly the watersport team. We also saw the manager around a fair bit, taking care of any issues arising.
Overall, this is the total package given the accommodation we had. We have been fortunate enough to stay in some of the best rated resorts in Phuket over the past few years and I would rate this as my favorite, with the private beach a fair contributor to this view. It is also very well priced compared to some of the other top rated resorts. Deserves a top rating and we hope to be back many times in the future after this, our first visit.