The owner Arie is one of the best people I met in what is known as West Bay. I spent much time on the island years back and his resort really offers the Cayman experience.
If you want a great time at a reasonable price, I highly suggest making a reservation. I am not an employee and not talking it up for any reason other than is serenity. I lived in Cayman as a kid and frankly, if you are on the west bay area, it is as close as you can get to how it was. Not clutter, very clean environment and the water is as clear as a pool.
Helen, a dive instructor is wonderful as is the rest of the staff. It really brought me back to how things were. I highly suggest giving it a go. You won't be disappointed! Its a smaller in with a wonderful dining facility and bar. Their dive shop and crew are top notch.
If you want to get away but be taken care of at the same time, I highly suggest making a reservation! If you wish to explore the island, you may wish to rent a car which can be had for around 45US per day but do keep in mind, gas is about 8.50US.More