My husband and I are planning our 1st trip to San Juan Island this coming September. I've been searching through as many websites as I can find for a vacation rental for 4 nights. I also came across A Windance Cottage and have it on the top of my list since it is avaiable for the time we plan on being there. Today I found "Haven On the Bay" which is on Westcott Bay. It's always hard to tell from the pictures but it looks pretty cool. Anyone have any input on it before I take a chance?