We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Parking in Greenwich Village?

Malua Bay, Australia
Level Contributor
169 posts
113 reviews
60 helpful votes
Parking in Greenwich Village?
Save

Hi Everyone,

Going to be in NY in Sept and hiring a car for 2 days (heading out of the city for 2 days) but are going back to our apartment to sleep at night. Will there be anywhere to park on or near Cornelia Street? If so what might parking charges be like?

We are thinking of asking the rental car company if we can park the car there overnight if parking is not an option. (It's about a 5 min walk away from the apartment).

Suggestions appreciated.

Thanks

New York City, New...
Level Contributor
11,517 posts
105 reviews
170 helpful votes
1. Re: Parking in Greenwich Village?
Save

www.bestparking.com

This site shows you parking garages in any area and the estimated cost.

You really do not need a rental car in NYC. Is there a reason you will have one? Why can't you rent it for 2 days and then return it, so you don't need to park it in Manhattan?

Are you staying with friends? I am concerned that you have mentioned an apartment in Greenwich Village - many vacation rentals in New York are scams or illegal. If you found it on www.vrbo.com or another rental site, please let us know the address so we can confirm it's on the up and up.

New York NY
Level Contributor
11,144 posts
99 reviews
83 helpful votes
2. Re: Parking in Greenwich Village?
Save

Street parking in Greenwich Village is very difficult. There is a very limited amount of parking and it is always fiercely competitive to get a space.

It really would be best to avoid having the car for the couple days you are in New York City.

As Kateoz mentioned, most short term apartment rentals in New York City are illegal (regardless of your experience in Paris or elsehwhere). There have been numerous cases recently of visitors arriving from Australia especially where they've paid for an apartment (and sometimes a "refundable" security deposit) only to learn that no such apartment exists and they've lost *ALL* their money. Be careful.

NYC/Israel
Destination Expert
for Israel
Level Contributor
45,147 posts
39 reviews
43 helpful votes
3. Re: Parking in Greenwich Village?
Save

The odds of the rental company allowing you to park are zero to none. Your best bet is finding a parking garage and paying. Understand that people who live in Manhattan frequently don't own cars and those that do will pay monthly rates that are more than what it cost for a two bedroom apartment in other parts of the US.

That being said--do you definitely need the vehicle for each of your day trips. If so--just pay the garage!

Malua Bay, Australia
Level Contributor
169 posts
113 reviews
60 helpful votes
4. Re: Parking in Greenwich Village?
Save

Thanks everyone for the quick replies.

We realise that a rental car in NY is less than ideal, but it's only for 2 days (we are there for 10). Public transport wouldn't be practial for where we are going out of the city. So a car is a must of these 2 days.

Thanks for the concern about the apartment, we researched it well and also purchased vacation rental protection. I'm pretty internet savy and didn't just book the first apartment that I found. I also requested additional photos, phone numbers etc etc. If anyone would be wanting to double check it for me, please PM me and I'll give you the details though.

London, United...
Destination Expert
for Wakefield
Level Contributor
6,210 posts
47 reviews
28 helpful votes
5. Re: Parking in Greenwich Village?
Save

If not a scam, it shouts illegal.

Thing is, I've got US phone numbers, you could call me on, they're even NYC based. So, that doesn't mean the person is in NYC. And, photos. well they're easy to come by, because you just make sure you have loads.

If you've booked for under 30 days, the apartment rental is illegal, and what could happen is that you're kicked out on the street. Worst case scenario, it won't actually exist.

I've never heard of Vacation Rental protection, will that basically pay full price for a hotel when you've been kicked out because it is illegal in the place you are staying? Or will that make it invalid? How not post the details on the forum?

Edited: 10 years ago
New York NY
Level Contributor
11,144 posts
99 reviews
83 helpful votes
6. Re: Parking in Greenwich Village?
Save

I'd be very concerned. The vacancy rate in Greenwich Village is extremely low and there are very few people (if any) holding on to spare apartments that they really want to spend time renting to visitors. The fact is that the scammers are really good and even one of your famous travel writers out of Melbourne - he thought he was super savvy - got scammed on an apartment rental. I'd be very concerned - it just doesn't smell right.

South Pole
Level Contributor
35 posts
6 reviews
17 helpful votes
7. Re: Parking in Greenwich Village?
Save

>You really do not need a rental car in NYC.

This is untrue.

I hired a car for a month last winter in NYC. Would definitely recommend. Have used street parking in Greenwich village in daytime feeding money in the meters or the expensive parking bays. Listen to local radio for 'alternative parking rules apply', it doesn't apply often but means you can almost park anywhere on the street free.

Positives of a rental car in NYC: You can do/see 10+ times more things than subway or taxi. NYC has the BEST shopping in the world and you can fill up the car. Drive to Atlantic City New Jersey etc. Driving across the Brooklyn bridge and through the suburbs listening to HOT97 eating a bagel is NYC culture in itself

You will be a baller compared to the sardines on the subway. TRUST.

I used Europcar in East Harlem and had no problems.

Maidstone, United...
Level Contributor
4,409 posts
5 reviews
6 helpful votes
8. Re: Parking in Greenwich Village?
Save

By the description, I'm guessing it's this apt:

http://www.vrbo.com/202933

In which case it would appear to be 37 Cornelia Street (looking at Google Street Maps) and, if so, guess what? The DOB has an outstanding complaint for "BLDG IN WHICH OWNER IS RENTING OUT APARTMENTS ILLEGALLY AS HOTEL ROOMS"

…nyc.gov/bisweb/OverviewForComplaintServlet…

Of course, it could be another apartment on Cornelia Street...

Malua Bay, Australia
Level Contributor
169 posts
113 reviews
60 helpful votes
9. Re: Parking in Greenwich Village?
Save

MaidstoneNic - No it's not that apartment, but yes I heard that was a scam.

New York City, New...
Destination Expert
for New York City
Level Contributor
109,132 posts
12 reviews
47 helpful votes
10. Re: Parking in Greenwich Village?
Save

hertz.com/rentacar/specialoffers/index.jsp…

$USD
United States

This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu.