We have lived almost forever in Madison, but my favorite place for pizza is in Milwaukee. Everytime we go to Milwaukee (about once a month), I don't try to wrangle an evening at Milwaukee's latest trendy restaurant but rather tell my husband that I want to go again to his high school hangout, Mama Mia's. I believe it's on Burleigh, Lisbon. It's the original. There are other Mama Mia's, one on Blue Mound, another on Silver Spring, but for the best pizza with the most toppings (one night I thought we got a whole can (yet, can - not fresh, but many and delicious) with our SMO (sausage, mushroom and onion). BTW, we can't stand the one on Silver Spring. The one on Blue Mound is equal with their garlic bread..maybe even better.. but not as generous on pizza toppings.
BTW, the appetizer before the pizza is their terrifc garlic bread. Something special in its self.
I should add the pizza is thin crust.