My girlfriend and I, both in our mid to late 20s, just purchased a couple of cheap tickets to San Juan, PR to get away for a week with plans to spend a night there and then puddle jump to either St. John or Culebra (tickets to either are about the same cost). We are planning on renting a car and camping while there, and I was hoping someone on this forum could help us out in our seemingly impossible decision between the two islands.
I have searched pretty adamently on the differences, and was hoping for some first hand knowledge that could help tip the scales. We both love the outdoors, love eating fresh local food for a good price, and love friendly people. We leave in two weeks. Thanks!