Who has the best fish and chips in Columbus? My husband and I loved the fish and chips at Buck Mulligan's, and they closed. Muholland Brewery also had great fish and chips...and they closed too! I have been to Old Bag, Claddaugh's, Marino's, The Pub at Polaris, Rusty Bucket and several other places in search of the best fish and chips....these places don't come close to Buck Mulligan's or M. Brewery! Help!!