Was looking at renting in the Hamptons and saw Shelter Island Hideaway on Trip Advisor. After doing some research online I found that this vacation rental property on Shelter Island to be very highly rated.
All the pictures online and the description made it look and absolutely beautiful and tranquil. I stayed there a few weeks ago and can absolutely say I was not disappointed at all. The place was charming. I felt as though I was on a Caribbean Island. We opened all the doors (I think there were like 18 of them) and let the outside in and they stayed open all day long. The only reason we closed them at night os we did not want any visits by deer :-)
The beach across the street was fabulous, the Island laid back, pristine, the restaurants great. We will surely be back again next year to stay, thinking about the larger house on the property next door and come back with friends! We unequivocally recommend Shelter Island Hideaway!!