Anyone know of a B&B in vicinity of LIRR stations bay Shore, Islip or somewhere near?
The closest place to stay near the train station is the Bay Shore Inn. Not a great option.
There's a Wingate by Wyndham with a Brentwood, NY address that gets good reviews and a Hampton Inn in Commack. I found all of these by plotting the Bay Shore train station on maps.google.com and then using the search nearby feature for hotels (and first tried b & b's).
There are lots of hotels near Islip MacArthur airport but that's not so close to the train station.