Planning a Bday trip for myself and significant other. A Friday and Sat night in June. I'm 36, he's 50. We're fun, lighthearted people who enjoy great dining and fun bar atmospheres. I'm torn between these two properties. The Carroll Inn is more affordable and the onsite Mad Batter rest/bar is a plus. The Star Inn appears to have nicer accommodations and includes the pool/beach services of Congress Hall. Hmmm. Can anyone provide any further insight into these properties?