I'm trying to plan a two night trip with my wife and (at the time) 11 month son in June. Close to home options are Keylime Cove north of Chicago, Grizzly Jacks at Starved Rock Illinois and Caribbean Cove in Indy. All are roughly the same distance and similarly priced.
My concern comes from the "reviews" of this place. Out of 226, 128 reviews are "terrible" but the vast vast majority are one hit wonders complaining about everything from bloody sheets and cockroaches to it being freezing cold and burning hot.
Is this place really that much of a dump? Should we avoid it totally? Anyone have any recent experience with it, or any of the others mentioned? I've been to Indy many many times but have always stayed with friends and have never had a reason to visit or go near this hotel, but have seen it in passing.
Thanks for any help!