We're getting married on Siesta Key in May and will have a few days to spend in the area after the wedding. We'd like to get away from Siesta since we'll have been there for a week and we'll have some lingering family members. We're probably flying out of Tampa so we'd like to go somewhere between Ft. Myers area and Tampa. What is a quiet, chill place where there won't be many people? We'd like to be beachfront and to spend under $200/night. A couple of nice restaurants nearby would be ideal, but we don't need any nightlife.
I've heard Captiva has a cool, laid-back vibe. I've also heard Anna Maria is pretty chill, but maybe more family-oriented?