We're heading to St. Augustine in November after a couple days in Savannah. We're are definitely not the B&B types, but the Casablanca Inn on the Bay seems to staddle the fence. We've read the reviews (tripadvisor.com/Hotel_Review-g34599-d117995-…) and the recent one lean mostly toward the good side. We do think if we stay, we'll opt for one of the two rooms on the 2nd floor that have a private balcony overlooking the Bay.
All that said, anyone stayed at Casablanca Inn on the Bay who might be able to provde some personal insight?