My husband and I are looking for a non-Mexico beach trip with our 15 month old toddler. Travel distance is an issue for us, and Key West is a decent ~4 hour flight total plus boat to Sunset Keys.
Sunset Keys seems to be a little more laid back and allows us some freedom to lay at beach or pool with monitor while toddler naps once a day. Key West itself seems rowdy though - - is it too rowdy? Obv a toddler cannot read explicit t-shirts etc, so that's not our main issue., but since we've never been we are unsure what it's like. We will be going mid to later May.
And please don't say for us to leave the baby at home. I am breastfeeding and we have no child care otherwise. Mother-in-law *may* come along, but we aren't relying on it.