Until last week I wasn't aware there are so many to choose from... the ratings on Tripadvisor for once do not help me at all since most resorts score very well! I hope the regulars can make this a bit easier for us. I've looked at most of them but it's hard to decide.
I've looked at advise for this type of question in the FAQ and so I'll try to make this as painless as possible!
Purpose of trip: First stage of the honeymoon, we want a quiet, relaxing place which can gives us privacy, both in the accommodation and in other places around the island.
Budget: 3500USD / 2500GBP for five nights.
Preferred board basis: It depends; I've seen resorts where the all-inclusive deal makes sense, others not so much. We love to drink cocktails so an all-inclusive deal which excludes cocktails is useless.
What time of year you intend to travel: Early October, five nights
Water villa with sunset views
Good house reef accessible from water villa or beach
Access stairs to the water from the villa
Good quality food
Nice to have:
Secluded feel to the island, so south atolls are preferable (not sure if this is correct)
Good choice in dining
No / very few children running around