And I can't believe there's no wifi... Well I should clarify with no free wifi.
Although I thought the pool was small in all the pictures I looked at, it's actually a good size. We love the view, happy hour drink specials, the cold water & lemonade at the beach, the wicker sofa on our lanai, the spa amenities that you can enjoy even if you don't pay for spa services, the themed gardens, the most amazing breakfast buffet I've ever had which is so filling I'm still not hungry and it's almost 7 hours later, the toadlets and toads we saw at dusk, the great beach and GREAT staff. I almost forgot to add the brownies & cookies at Koele, the bath amenities especially the woolite to wash out our bathing suits, the child size robes, the lei making class, the free use of tennis courts up at Koele (which isn't as long a ride as I thought it would be) the croquet, the amazing gardens and the atmosphere up there.
I'm not so crazy about the walk to the beach, (I didn't think it was so far) or the lack of pineapple on my piña colada, Or the $14/day charge for Internet, but otherwise we are sooooo GLAD we went out of our way to come here.
Thanks everyone for your advice.