We have used Trip Advisor reviews in the past for accommodation and cars and they have been accurate,
Just came back from 15 days near Captain Cook in a VRBO property. Number was VRBO 458131
It was a quite good budget apt, but neither the reviews or the owners summary mentioned:
It was not possible to lock the apt. up
The neighbours have a noisy dog, that became quite tiresome.
Would be more cautious in future with VRBO reviews