Here’s my review of Little Cay. We only spent two days there in December.
Little to no swimmer’s beach: If you are expecting lots of great sand to walk around or lay out on, it’s not there. As with much of the Caribbean, the “beach” is pretty much all rock. You’ll need to bring water shoes for pretty much the entire time. You can’t really walk anywhere (on the island, on the beach, or in the water) without shoes.
Offsetting this by far though is the water and snorkeling. The colors of the water are gorgeous. Turquois like you would see in Cozumel. The underwater life is really great (granted I’m an amateur snorkeler so take it for what it’s worth). The thing that I thought was really great was how easy it was to get to see some pretty great stuff. You can go down off the ladder at the end of the northeast pier and just lower yourself into the water and see some great fish, plants, and coral. So even if you aren’t comfortable swimming you can just hold onto the ladder and still have some of the experience. Off the south side of the island, you can walk out several feet where the water is just 3 to 4 feet deep and stick your head underneath and see some good fish. Butterfly fish for example. There’s plenty more for the more adventurous but I’m just trying to make the point that even if you aren’t very comfortable with the water there will be some opportunity for you.
There’s a cat on the island. They said they put him there to keep the rats away. I never saw any mice, but the cat is quite annoying. He sticks to you like glue. Not matter how many doors and windows you close, he always find a way back in to where you are. He’s like a ghost. He can be annoying at night, constantly meowing. It kept us awake quite a bit. Ironically, when we arrived on the island we kept hearing the cat meow, but we couldn’t find him. Finally I found him shut in a closet. Apparently the previous renters had gotten sick of him and locked him up there. When I let him out I was pretty appalled that someone would do this. After a few hours of having him out, I understood a lot more clearly how it could happen.
Cleanliness. Only so-so. Sheets are not completely clean by any means. Looked like some towels had just been left hanging to dry from the previous renters. No way to know for sure, but that’s what it looked like. Not all dishes were perfectly clean either. Not dirty from food. Maybe just from sitting around and lack of use. Just dusty.
Not hot water. If you are going in a really hot month, this may be no problem. We went in December so it was pretty cool. The shower was quite painful. I had to go really fast.
Kitchen. Very spacious. Plenty of pots and pans, dishes, and silverware. It was somewhat primitive and old. Much of the silverware had rust spots. Gas stove and oven. A fridge (somewhat small). We had one dishtowel and an old sponge to wash with.
The house (not counting the cabin). I thought the house was really great. Very spacious. 3 bedrooms. One room has a double and a single bed in it, another 2 doubles and a single, and another a double and 2 singles. The dining room and living room are very spacious as well. Dining room has a table for 8 – 10. There are also bar stools at the bar in the kitchen. The living room has all outdoor furniture. Not as comfortable as your nice living room furniture, but it serves its purpose. They have a few books there as well as a puzzle and a Jenga game. We didn't use the cabin, so I can't really comment. It has a double and a single bed.
Rock wall. There’s a 3-foot rock wall built around a lot of the island. This is good because it blocks the waves and creates a little shallow pool – maybe 3 feet deep in the deepest part – that little kids can play around in if they aren’t comfortable getting in the real ocean. It’s still rocky here though and they’d have to wear shoes.
No TV or internet. If you want these things you really shouldn’t be coming here. If you happen to have a Honduran cell phone (Tigo) you can get a signal on the island though.
Not quite as remote as Sandy Cay. There’s another island relatively close to Little Cay. One way to explain it is to say that I didn’t feel completely comfortable running around nude everywhere because of the proximity of other island (of course just because I didn’t feel completely comfortable doesn’t mean I didn’t do it.) When we were leaving the island, we asked him to run us over to Sandy Cay quickly just so we could see what it looked like. I prefer Little Cay. The house is quite a bit nicer. Sandy Cay has way more sandy beaches though, so if that’s what you are after you should go there. There’s not that much difference between the two. Sandy is longer and narrower; Little is more rounded.
In case this seems like a long list of complaints, I don’t mean it that way. We had a great time and plan to go back. It truly is an island paradise. I mainly want people to be prepared for what it is. If you are picky and finicky about things, if you love big all-inclusive resorts and eating out, if you are not the type who would go camping (like in a tent) for several days, you might want to think pretty hard before going here. You need to be the type who can improvise if you forget something or if something is unavailable make do with what you have. Once you are there, you are there. It’s not easy to run to Walmart.