My wife and I looking to book our first trip to Belize this year. I think we are set on staying in San Pedro but would like to get some recommendations as to where to stay. We are looking for something on the beach, quaint, nothing over the top fancy and not too big. Preferably close to (walking or biking distance) some restaurants and bars as well. Pool with some on-site dining and activities as well would be nice. Meal plans aren't necessary but we wouldn't mind breakfast to be included. We're not divers but more of a combination of beach people who like to get out and explore.
Thanks in advance for all replies.