My husband and I stayed in Blue Reef in 2008 when we visited AC. We loved that it was away from town -- peaceful, quiet, and beautiful -- and they gave us free rides on their water taxi whenever they went into town. It was a perfect world of accessibility to San Pedro and tranquility.
However, it seems they are closed now?? Are there any other places that offer this option? We don't want to pay tons for water taxis, as we will be bringing our (adventurous) young kids and every other day round trips for four can get expensive!