After much thought and exhaustive research, I've narrowed it down to Hotel d'Aubusson and Villa d'Estrees. Both 4-star hotels, essentially in the same area.
I love the way the rooms look at d'Estrees, they seem very spacious and well-decorated, while I've heard the rooms at d'Aubusson aren't as charming? (maybe the pictures don't do it justice) However, the staff may be more friendly and helpful at d'Aubusson? I haven't read a bad review of the d'Aubusson.
Has anyone stayed at either of these hotels and can comment?