I realize this is a very specific question buy I'm always impressed by what TA people share.
I think we've narrowed it down to these two choices (1 in Punta Cana - Bahia Prinicipe Ambar and 1 in the Mayan- El Dorado Seaside Suites), flying out of Montreal on March Break. We are prioritizing an AO because it will be Spring Break and don't want to be over run with kids.
That being said we would love to hear the pros and cons of each choice. We've never been anywhere in the Dominican and our last stay in Mexico was Gran Bahia Principe Coba. The Coba was good because we were with our own kids and there was lots of activity but we probably want somewhere medium sized (lots to do but not Disney either :-). We also love to snorkel and the most memorable part of Mexico for us was going to Akumal Beach. We didn't really enjoy snorkelling off the beach at the Coba.
Any one out there who could weigh in on the better choice - Bahia Principe Ambar and El Dorado Seaside Suites? (both are about the same price)