My boyfriend and I are planning to go to Cozumel for 5-7 days (depending on the deal we can find) for the last week in July. We are having a hard time deciding if we want to do AI or not. Though I love the idea off all the Margarita's I can drink, I also like to try new places and I fear wasting $ on AI and the food be horrible. Another issue we are having is finding a reasonably priced hotel with a decent beach that we can walk on/walk into the ocean (as opposed to the dive resorts where you just get in at 5 ft +). Does anyone have any suggestions as to hotels/beaches and restaurants? Are the restaurants reasonably priced?