Shoot me a must do list please.
You will get a long list. Neither of those places would be on my top list but I know some will disagree. For the top restaurant in town, I vote for La Cocay.
Would love to hear everyones best.
Good list by Dan. A good range of choices.
Buccano's, Blue Angel, La Cocay, El Pique, Kinta.
I would need more info on YOUR definition of "must do". What do you like? What is your budget? Do you eat seafood or not? Hole in the wall places or a fancy dinner? As others have said, you will eventually get a list with every restaurant on the island. Everyone has their personal favs. I suggest you read the restaurant reviews here and decide which sound like something to YOUR liking....not mine. If you have more specific questions...come on back to us.
I know I personally would like to go somewhere for a lobster dinner when I am there if someone could recommend a good seafood restaurant