We just spent a week on Cat Island. My wife and I spent the week having the best vacation we ever had. We have spent a lot of time in the Bahamas, and without any question this was the best resort we have ever been to. We did spend time looking at all the other resorts and found Greenwood the biggest disappointment without any questions, Hawkes Nest would be great for scuba folks and those who want to be near a marina. Shawnas cove resort is new and could be a great stop, it is their first year and at the far north end of the island, so you decide.
I will tell you, the staff, Evan, Donna and Kaylie and the cooks are the best I have ever seen. A++++++++