I'm staying at Shangri-La on Cat Island next week. We're debating the car. I've been to Cat before, but can recall how far it was from Bennett's Harbour to other things. We're good walkers, so if there is a restaurant or two within a couple miles (each way), we're fine without a car. I'm also thinking there are bikes there, so I can make the ride into town for supplies. We did the sights last time and want really just to park ourselves on the beach and relax for a few days - so if I get a car, I'll barely use it.