I LOVE St. John, but my hubby wants to try someplace new. Which of these would you choose and why? I found pretty good deals to the Buccaneer and to Sandals on St. Lucia. We have never done an all inclusive. One of the things I love about St. John is having our own place to stay, riding around in our jeep, snorkeling(!!), and doing our own thing. Because of this I question if I would really like a crowded Sandals resort, although it would be nice to be waited on. Thanks for your input!