Looking to visit the Virgin Islands for the first time with my girlfriend sometime in the late spring/early summer. Hoping to rent a villa, perhaps the Captains House in Tortola, and have a long list of possibles for St John. Wondering which island might be the better choice. We like to have a good time, will spend the majority of our days hiking, snorkeling, beach bars, etc. Any input will be greatly appreciated! Both look so incredibly gorgeous!