My boyfriend and I are going to St. John in early March and would love some advice. We are currently staying for 10 days (at the Westin on points) - is this too long? We've debated whether to go to Tortola or Virgin Gorda for a couple of days, but thinking it might be nice to have a home base in St. John and just do day trips. Any thoughts?
Also for how many days should we rent a car? Any beaches/day trips that are absolute musts? My boyfriend loves to fish - any recommendations?
We are 30 yrs old, no kids, mostly going to relax and will happily sit by the pool for a couple of days. But are also both pretty athletic people who want to get the most out of the trip and don't want to get antsy being in one place for too long.
Thanks in advance for any input!