Has anyone been to both resorts and can help us decide for a trip in November? We visited the Four Seasons a few years back for about an hour and thought it looked very nice, but we did not stay there and did not see any other part of Nevis. We stayed on St Kitts and were disapointed. We love St John and return to Caneel Bay every year. So I think that we probably would like Peter Island too but would love to hear from some savy travelers who might help us decide. Thanks!