After doing so much research my brain hurts, but I think I have narrowed it down to PPC vs STB. Deciding factors:
Unlimited drinks of any kind at both? or are there restrictions?
Mini-bar with booze in room? (we like our alcohol, what can I say)
Are lounge chairs and umbrellas available at no charge?
Pool and/or beach wait service at either?
Which resort has the most activities? We have a big group of singles and couples looking for some fun in the sun and relaxation.
(and maybe a little golf)
Any additional hidden costs at one versus the other? I like to be able to go to an all-inclusive and not have to open my wallet.