I'm trying to find somewhere to go for my honeymoon, but I'm finding it hard to decide where to go. All of the information I find on the Caribbean islands is positive, so it's making it hard for me to make a decision. I thought about going to Grenada, but then I read so many mixed reviews it was hard to make a decision. I'm looking to go somewhere that isn't super touristy; I envision being a major beach bum, so I don't really want to be somewhere with crowded beach. I spent a summer on Guam and loved it because it was not too big, not too touristy, but still had fun activities like dolphin watching, snorkeling, and a fun little place to go shopping for island jewelry and crafts. Something similiar would be an amazing vacation for my fiance and I. We don't need an all-inclusive, typical resorty-touristy filled honeymoon. Any suggestions?? Thanks.