First, thank you RandB for your help with Whitehouse. We love it here (leaving tomorrow). I requested Dutch 4th floor and that's what we got!
Now on to the question. Where to go next? We have been to SGSL twice (our favorite) SN once (ehh...it was ok) SA once (nope,never again. Food was horrible and I got food poisoning) and now SW (our second favorite).
A good beach. I prefer to walk right in w/o water shoes but wearing them at SW hasn't been much of an issue.
Snorkeling off the beach like SGSL would be great
Plenty of palapas or umbrellas for when we get to hot but still want to be on the beach. We've spent the whole week on the beach (aside from one day) at SW and thus far my biggest complaint is/was getting up at 6am to get beach chairs with umbrellas. Oh yes, towel game in full swing.
Able to walk off property with out vendors hassling us. We loved pigeon island at SGSL and have loved going off property here at SW.
Room service 24/7 for Club level would be awesome or at least a better 7:30am-10:30pm menu than SW (very very limited menu but we've made due a couple times).
Ocean front balcony or at the very least ocean view (like SA Med side and SGSL back side).
I think that's about it.
As a side note, we are only looking to go Club level. Basic is to basic and butler is to costly.
Grenada is out as there are no good flights from any airport with in three hrs from us.
Bahamas is out as I'm afraid the water would be to cold for me in March (Antigua was to cold for me in March and water temp was 72).
We are not opposed to coming back here but would love to try another one.