THE 10 BEST Pizza Places in Lancaster

Sort by:

Highest Rating

Looking to expand your search outside of Lancaster? We have suggestions.

Expand your search.

1. Luca on James

214 reviews

Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu

“Inviting atmosphere and terrific pizza”

“... had the Margherita pizza which was ...”

2. The Fridge

145 reviewsOpen Now

American, Bar$$ - $$$

“Quick, delicious dinner”

“If you can’t find a beer you like, you...”

3. Salt & Pepper Italian Bistro Pizza

92 reviewsOpen Now

Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$

“Great Family Restaurant”

“Rude Manager”

4. A Slice of Brooklyn Pizza

87 reviewsOpen Now

Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu

“GREAT pizza”

“Keeping safe”

5. Pasquale's Italian Garden and Pizzeria

218 reviewsOpen Now

Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu

“Good food”

“In Lancaster for a weekend”

6. Cicis

62 reviewsOpen Now

Quick Bites, Pizza$Menu

“Made us very sick”

“Great pizza variety, price and management”

7. Rosa Rosa Pizzeria

13 reviewsOpen Now

Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$

“Rosa Rosa Remarkable!”

“Take out”

8. Caruso's Italian Restaurant

22 reviewsOpen Now

Italian, Pizza$Menu

“A Hidden Gem”

“One of our favorite Italian restaurants”

9. Mod Pizza

19 reviewsOpen Now

Quick Bites, Pizza$Menu

“Great Pizza!”

“I LOVE their pizza!”

10. MOD

18 reviews

Pizza, Fast Food$Menu

“Wanted a quick bite....”

“Awesome pizza made your way!”

11. Alley Kat

47 reviewsOpen Now

Pizza, American$Menu

“The pizza was as wonderful as I remembered it.”

“Such a fun stop!”

12. Dominion Pizza

21 reviewsOpen Now

Pizza, Italian$$ - $$$Menu

“Randomly found this spot while”

“quick bite”

13. Steel Peel Pennslyvania Pizza Company

10 reviewsOpen Now

Italian, Pizza$Menu

“Favorite pizza place in Lancaster”

“Your next favorite pizza place”

14. Infinito's Pizza Buffett

22 reviewsOpen Now

Pizza, Italian$Menu

“great variety of pizza”

“Infinito's”

15. Vinny and Thoze Guyz Pizzeria

21 reviewsOpen Now

Pizza$Menu

“Outstanding. We were looking”

“Under new ownership”

16. Pasquale's Restaurant

21 reviewsOpen Now

Pizza, Italian$$ - $$$Menu

“Just ok”

“Good Italian food and atmosphere”

17. Ruffino's Pizza & Pasta

23 reviews

Pizza, Italian$

“Great pizza”

“Parking is fine as it uses the large st...”

18. Espino's Pizzas, Pastas & Subs

9 reviews

Pizza$

“Great little hole in the wall”

“BEST VEGAN PIZZA in Lancaster”

19. Slugger's Pizzeria

18 reviewsOpen Now

Pizza$

“GREAT PIZZA NEAR THE BALL PARK!!!”

“A great lunch time stop for a meal.”

20. Federal Taphouse

259 reviewsOpen Now

American, Bar$$ - $$$

“flat beer, mediocre food, poor atmosphere”

“Several visits now and I'll keep going...”

21. Neto's pizza

19 reviewsOpen Now

Italian, Pizza$

“I Will Never Know Since They Were Closed...”

Pizza$Menu

“A great place for Pizza Delivery”

Pizza, Italian$

11 reviewsOpen Now

Pizza$Menu

“Best pizza!!!”

“You cannot best their prices and I’ve never had a pizza that wasn’t amazing!”

25. Two Cousin's Pizza

32 reviewsOpen Now

Pizza, Italian$$ - $$$Menu

“A great stop right before heading to our...”

“Lunch”

26. House of Pizza

44 reviewsOpen Now

Pizza, Italian$

“sandwiches to go”

“Awful customer service”

27. Pats Pizzeria

20 reviewsOpen Now

Pizza$$ - $$$

“Went there many times for pizza at lunc...”

“Every pizza I have gotten has been good...”

28. Domino's Pizza

2 reviewsOpen Now

Pizza

“Consistently great”

“Sunday pizza”

29. Randazzo's Pizza and Pasta

14 reviewsOpen Now

Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu

“Pretty good pizza”

“Fast Fast service, great food and...”

30. Caruso's Pizzeria

10 reviewsOpen Now

Pizza$$ - $$$Menu

“Great pizza!”

“Good pizza except the crust”

Previous Next

1 2 3

Best Pizza in Lancaster, Lancaster County

Pizza Places in Lancaster