We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Pizza Places in Utica

Filter and search through restaurants with gift card offerings.
See restaurants with gift cards
View map
Map
Satellite
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Establishment Type
Show more
Restaurant features
Show more
Meals
Reservations
Price
Cuisine
Show more
Dishes
Show more
Dietary Restrictions
Good for
Sort by:
Highest Rating
We found great results, but some are outside Utica. Showing results in neighboring cities.
Limit search to Utica.
1. Jonnys PIzza
47 reviews
Pizza, Italian$Menu
“Used to be great! Not anymore :(”
“Food not up to par ... paid extra too”
2. O'scugnizzo Pizzeria
117 reviewsClosed Now
Italian, Pizza$Menu
“Excellent Pizza!”
“Tomato Pie”
3. Franco's Pizza & Italian Deli
24 reviewsClosed Now
Pizza, Italian$Menu
“Perfect Pizza & Wings”
“Not a good experience”
4. Charlie's Pizza North Utica
32 reviewsClosed Now
Italian, Pizza$Menu
“Charlie's pizza is always a nice place for a family, casual dinner.”
“Fact is, pizza and salad was a great choice.”
5. O'scugnizzo North Utica
9 reviews
Pizza, Italian$Menu
“Our First Upside Down Pizza”
“Easy thruway spot t get sauce all over...”
6. Lukins Brick Oven Pizza
21 reviewsClosed Now
Bar, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu
“Pizza, drinks, and/or live music........can't lose!”
“The BEST Pizza in Town”
7. Parkway Pizza
8 reviews
Italian, Pizza
“Had better TV dinners!”
“This place is amazing”
8. Pie Squared
2 reviews
American, Bar
“Pie Squared”
“Delicious!”
9. Slice
21 reviewsClosed Now
Pizza, Italian$Menu
“Great pizza and boneless wings.”
“Good New York style pizza.”
10. Palermo Pizzeria
17 reviewsClosed Now
Pizza, Italian$Menu
“Tasty Sub but with little meat”
“The best pizza in upstate New York!”
11. Alberto's Pizzeria
“My Uncle works at this place and is...”
“By far the BEST pizza in Utica”
12. Domino's Pizza
2 reviewsClosed Now
Pizza
“Standard Chain Pizza”
“What do you expect”
13. Rosario's Pizzeria East Utica
12 reviewsClosed Now
Italian, Pizza
“Absolutely Fantastic!”
“best ever”
14. Venice Pizzeria
42 reviewsClosed Now
Italian, Pizza$Menu
2.2 mi
Yorkville
“Got a large meatball sub her”
“I gave you 3 shots and you have failed me...”
15. Tony's Pizzeria
16 reviewsClosed Now
Quick Bites, Italian$Menu
“Terrible Pizza”
“Sad!”
16. Trio's Pizza
8 reviewsClosed Now
Pizza$
2.4 mi
New York Mills
“13 Myths About Keto Hack”
“Pizza”
17. Little Caesars
1 reviewClosed Now
Pizza
“Don't. Just Don't.”
18. Pizza Boys
47 reviewsClosed Now
Pizza, Italian$Menu
2.8 mi
New York Mills
“Good Take Out”
“Very good service and food.”
19. Joe's Pizza
44 reviewsClosed Now
Italian, Pizza$
3.1 mi
Whitesboro
“Loved their pizza for years!”
“Best Upsided down Pizza”
20. O'Baby's Gourmet Sandwich Shoppe
26 reviewsClosed Now
Pizza, American$
2.7 mi
New Hartford
“Best Chicken Noodle Soup”
“Delicious sandwiches and wings.”
21. Charlie's Pizza
11 reviewsClosed Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$
3.0 mi
Whitesboro
“Best Pizza and Wings”
“Usually Great. But very disappointed”
22. Franco's Pizza
9 reviewsClosed Now
Pizza$Menu
2.8 mi
Whitesboro
“Lunch”
“Love their submarine sandwiches”
23. Franco's Pizzeria
17 reviewsClosed Now
Quick Bites, Italian$Menu
3.5 mi
Whitesboro
“Crappy Pizza seriously”
“Great pizza”
24. Charlie's Pizza
20 reviews
Italian, PizzaMenu
3.4 mi
Washington Mills
“Good Pizza”
“good pizza”
25. Mangia Macrina's Wood Fired Pizza
18 reviewsClosed Now
Pizza$Menu
3.6 mi
New Hartford
“Excellent”
“Just okay but, less than I expected”
26. Little Caesars
2.8 mi
Yorkville
“Pizza was so undercook it fell apart”
“consistent taste”
27. Tom Cavallo's Restaurant
127 reviewsClosed Now
Italian, American$$ - $$$Menu
2.8 mi
New Hartford
“Take Out”
“Overrated, disappointing”
28. Tonys Pizzeria & Deli
9 reviewsClosed Now
Pizza, ItalianMenu
4.2 mi
New Hartford
“Good food and prices”
“Excellent Pizza”
29. Tony's of Washington Mills
12 reviewsClosed Now
Pizza, Italian$Menu
3.4 mi
New Hartford
“Superior Pizza and Wings”
“Service is poor. I have a feeling that...”
30. John's Pizzeria
3.2 mi
Marcy
“Love those steaks subs”
“"Pizza And More"”
© 2021 TripAdvisor LLC All rights reserved.
Terms of UsePrivacy and Cookies StatementSite MapHow the site works

This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu.