We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Want the lowest hotel prices? You're in the right place. We check 200+ sites for you.

Restaurants in Shelter Island

The Frisky Oyster
$$$$, American, Seafood, International
Greenport 2.4 mi away
Sterlington Deli
$, American, Delicatessen
Greenport 2.5 mi away
Stars Cafe
$, American, Cafe
The Islander
$, American, Diner
Commander Cody's
$, American, Seafood
Pizza (7)
Seafood (32)
Mexican (7)
Italian (15)
American (68)
American (73)
Seafood (33)
Bar (24)
18 Bay
$$$$
Find a table
Vine Street Cafe
$$$$, American
Find a table
The Tavern at Shelter Island House
$$ - $$$, American, Grill, Bar
Find a table
Noah's
$$ - $$$, American, Seafood
Greenport 2.5 mi away
Find a table
Sort by:
Ranking
Name
We found great results, but some are outside Shelter Island. Showing results within 25 mi of Shelter Island.
Limit search to Shelter Island.

18 Bay

#1 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$$$ Map
Visitor photos (23)
Reserve

Vine Street Cafe

#2 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$$$ Map
Visitor photos (9)
Menu
Cuisines: American
Reserve

Salt

#3 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (36)
Menu
Cuisines: American Bar Seafood

Marie Eiffel Market

#4 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (29)
Menu

Lucharito's (Greenport, NY 2.4 mi away)

#1 of 45 Restaurants in Greenport
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (40)
Menu
Cuisines: Mexican Southwestern Latin Bar Spanish Pub

The Frisky Oyster (Greenport, NY 2.4 mi away)

#2 of 45 Restaurants in Greenport
$$$$ Map
Visitor photos (13)
Menu

Sterlington Deli (Greenport, NY 2.5 mi away)

#3 of 45 Restaurants in Greenport
$ Map
Visitor photos (5)
Menu

Stars Cafe

#5 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$ Map
Visitor photos (20)
Menu
Cuisines: American Cafe

Rams Head Inn Restaurant (Shelter Island Heights)

#6 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$$$ Map
Visitor photos (34)
Menu
Cuisines: American

Sweet Tomato's (Shelter Island Heights)

#7 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (8)
Menu
Cuisines: Italian

Maria's kitchen

#8 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (2)
Menu
Cuisines: Mexican

Sunset Beach (Shelter Island Heights)

#9 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$$$ Map
Visitor photos (11)
Menu
Cuisines: French American Bar Seafood Pub

The Tavern at Shelter Island House

#10 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (10)
Menu
Cuisines: American Grill Bar Seafood Pub
Reserve

The Islander

#11 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$ Map
Visitor photos (3)
Menu
Cuisines: American Diner

Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market (Greenport, NY 2.4 mi away)

#4 of 45 Restaurants in Greenport
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (39)
Menu
Cuisines: American Seafood

Commander Cody's

#12 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$ Map
Visitor photos (8)
Menu
Cuisines: American Seafood

Noah's (Greenport, NY 2.5 mi away)

#5 of 45 Restaurants in Greenport
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (44)
Menu
Cuisines: American Seafood
Reserve

Kyle's

#13 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (16)
Menu
Cuisines: American

Southold Fish Market (Southold, NY 3.0 mi away)

#2 of 25 Restaurants in Southold
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (4)
Menu
Cuisines: American Seafood Soups

Shelter Island Craft Brewery

#14 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$ Map
Visitor photos (10)
Menu
Cuisines: Bar Pub

Salamander's On Front (Greenport, NY 2.5 mi away)

#6 of 45 Restaurants in Greenport
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (20)
Menu
Cuisines: American

Red Maple

#15 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (8)
Menu
Cuisines: American Bar Seafood Contemporary

Shelter Island Heights Pharmacy (Shelter Island Heights)

#16 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Map
Visitor photos (3)
Menu

The Pridwin Restaurant

#17 of 24 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$ - $$$
Visitor photos (18)
Menu
Cuisines: Seafood American

First and South (Greenport, NY 2.5 mi away)

#7 of 45 Restaurants in Greenport
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (14)
Menu
Cuisines: American Bar

North Fork Table (Southold, NY 4.1 mi away)

#1 of 25 Restaurants in Southold
$$$$ Map
Visitor photos (28)
Menu
Cuisines: American
Reserve

American Beech (Greenport, NY 2.5 mi away)

#9 of 45 Restaurants in Greenport
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (17)
Menu
Cuisines: Seafood American
Reserve

1943 Pizza Bar (Greenport, NY 2.6 mi away)

#8 of 45 Restaurants in Greenport
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (5)
Menu
Cuisines: Italian Pizza

Tuck Shop (Shelter Island Heights)

#1 of 1 Dessert in Shelter Island
$ Map
Visitor photos (1)
Menu

Claudio's Restaurant (Greenport, NY 2.4 mi away)

#11 of 45 Restaurants in Greenport
$$ - $$$ Map
Visitor photos (94)
Menu
Cuisines: American Bar Seafood Soups