We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Restaurants in Siesta Key

View map
Map
Satellite
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
COVID-19
Establishment Type
Show more
Restaurant features
Show more
Meals
Price
Cuisine
Show more
Dishes
Show more
Dietary Restrictions
Good for
Show more
Sort by:
Highest Rating
We found great results, but some are outside Siesta Key. Showing results in neighboring cities.
Limit search to Siesta Key.
1. Made in Rome Organic Gelato
170 reviewsClosed Now
Dessert$Menu
“One of the most exquisite ice cream I ever tried !!!”
“... which was to die for- you must put this ice cream store on your bucket list-”
2. Summer House Steak & Seafood
353 reviewsClosed Now
Steakhouse, Seafood$$$$Menu
“Caesar salad was great!!! Surf and turf melted in my mouth.”
“My husband had the lobster and I had the lamb and the food was delicious.”
3. Meaney's Mini Donuts
429 reviewsOpen Now
Bakeries, American$
1.0 mi
Sarasota
“... sundae and the French toast donuts.”
“... and the turtle cheesecake flavors.”
4. Big Water Fish Market
1,267 reviewsClosed Now
Seafood, Soups$$ - $$$Menu
“Excellent seafood - definitely a must try!”
“Our toddler enjoyed the very tasty fish stew and the snapper was to die for.”
5. The Cottage
2,144 reviewsClosed Now
American, Bar$$ - $$$Menu
“We had the Lobster Maki Roll and Forbidden Salmon, which were elegantly prepa...”
“My brother had the ahi tacos and truffle fries and said they were wonderful a...”
Sponsored
Gelato-go Sarasota
46 reviewsClosed Now
Dessert, Cafe$Menu
4.8 mi
Sarasota
“Best Italian ice cream in Sarasota”
“I love gelato more than ice cream and this place does not disappoint.”
6. Sun Garden Cafe
1,003 reviewsClosed Now
American, Cafe$$ - $$$Menu
“The blt with egg and guacamole whole grain bread was wonderful...”
“The biscuits and gravy and the avocado toast were the biggest hits.”
7. Village Cafe
572 reviewsClosed Now
American, Cafe$$ - $$$Menu
“... eggs ($9.95) and the breakfast burrito (chorizo, eggs, tomato, cheese and...”
“... took some home, the other had 2 pancakes, eggs and sausage and also took ...”
8. Big Olaf Creamery
1,073 reviewsClosed Now
Dessert, American$Menu
“We went to big Olaf every night of vaca for a waffle cone.”
“A Vacation Tradition”
9. Another Broken Egg Cafe
707 reviewsClosed Now
American, Cafe$$ - $$$Menu
“The beignets were out of this world good!! Drinks were awesome, heavy pour w...”
“Shrimp and grits Crawfish skillet Chili chilaquilrs Astounding pitchers of Bl...”
10. The Orange Octopus
424 reviewsClosed Now
Dessert, American$
1.6 mi
Sarasota
“Must ADD Orange Octopus to your Siesta Key Bucket List!”
“Orange Octopus features 24 flavors of home-made ice cream made on site, along...”
Sponsored
Michael's On East
818 reviewsClosed Now
American, Seafood$$$$Menu
4.0 mi
Sarasota
“... Mark and Niki, who recommended swordfish over Michael's signature flounder.”
“The food, however, was glorious, we tried the duck appetiser with the angels...”
11. Miguel's Restaurant
804 reviewsClosed Now
French$$ - $$$Menu
“Then I had the tilapia almondine, which is easily one of the best fish entree...”
“Be sure to order Chateaubriand for Two and Bananas Foster for Two”
12. Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream
411 reviewsClosed Now
Dessert, American$Menu
“Hidden Gem”
“Not Dippin Dots”
13. Abel's Ice Cream
539 reviewsClosed Now
Dessert, American$Menu
1.8 mi
Sarasota
“Excellent ice cream and service”
“Great ice cream without the crowds”
14. Bonjour French Cafe
995 reviewsClosed Now
American$$ - $$$Menu
“My wife had the american breakfast and my friend had the french toast, all am...”
“LaParisian omelet is great!”
15. Toasted Mango Cafe
656 reviewsClosed Now
American, Cafe$$ - $$$Menu
“Perfect beach breakfast spot”
“Enjoyable Brunch!”
Sponsored
Daiquiri Deck Siesta Key Village
1,618 reviewsOpen Now
American, Bar$$ - $$$Menu
“The grilled salmon and mixed greens had a fun combination of items but I pers...”
“This time we ordered meals, wild caught Salmon Salad, Oyster Po-Boy, Salmon w...”
16. Cafe Gabbiano
671 reviewsClosed Now
Italian, Tuscan$$$$Menu
1.0 mi
Sarasota
“... bruschetta, calamari, brie with war...”
“... and the lobster ravioli shared at t...”
17. Clayton's Siesta Grille
1,080 reviewsClosed Now
Seafood$$ - $$$Menu
1.6 mi
Sarasota
“I think the best salmon I've ever had and such a great variety on the menu!”
“Had the mussels and meatballs which were delicious.”
18. Lobster Pot Restaurant
1,272 reviewsClosed Now
American, Seafood$$ - $$$Menu
“Delicious fresh seafood in an intimate restaurant.”
“Awesome cornbread!”
19. The Hub Baja Grill
2,764 reviewsOpen Now
Mexican, American$$ - $$$Menu
“... chicken quesadilla, baja salad, grouper sandwich, and chicken burrito.”
“... as well as the Tijuana Cobb, chicken quesadilla, Cuban sandwich...”
20. Isan Thai Restaurant
346 reviewsClosed Now
Asian, Thai$$ - $$$Menu
1.3 mi
Sarasota
“Crispy duck was wonderful.”
“I especially enjoy the Pineapple Green Curry Fried Rice, as well as the Panan...”
Sponsored
Speaks Clam Bar St Armands
268 reviewsClosed Now
Italian, American$$ - $$$Menu
3.9 mi
Sarasota
“Try the hot lobster roll.”
“The best NY Strip and scallops with shrimp scampi and linguini ever!”
21. Flavio's Brick Oven and Bar
672 reviewsClosed Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu
0.9 mi
Sarasota
“Try the calamari or the stuffed ravioli.”
“Second time i brought my son the calamari was great as well as the service on...”
22. The Siesta Key Oyster Bar
2,461 reviewsOpen Now
American, Bar$$ - $$$Menu
0.9 mi
Sarasota
“You can’t beat their Happy Hour for raw oysters from 3:00-6:00 daily.”
“The burrata salad was delicious- my meal was a 10/10!”
23. Pho 101 Noodle House
173 reviewsClosed Now
Vietnamese, Soups$$ - $$$
1.6 mi
Sarasota
“My wife likes the salmon salad, too.”
“And the blackend tuna salad was incredi...”
24. Anna's II
188 reviewsClosed Now
Quick Bites, American$Menu
1.6 mi
Sarasota
“Excellent Sandwiches!”
“Fantastic made to order sandwiches.”
25. Dolce Italia
1,019 reviewsClosed Now
Italian$$ - $$$
2.2 mi
Sarasota
“WOW! Incredible homemade pasta!”
“My husband had their signature seafood linguine.....just spectacular!”
Sponsored
Turtle Beach Grill
342 reviewsClosed Now
Seafood, Grill$$ - $$$Menu
4.0 mi
Sarasota
“We enjoyed the Caesar wrap and grouper sandwich.”
“Get the grouper fish tacos!”
26. Island House Tap & Grill
420 reviewsOpen Now
American, Pub$$ - $$$Menu
“We had the fresh sea bass ceviche, which was one of the best I've had.”
“The fish tacos, burgers and salads are all great.”
27. Ophelia's on the Bay
1,423 reviewsClosed Now
American, International$$$$
“Crab cakes and egg plant crepes were to die for and my scallops were the best...”
“Service was so very friendly and the oysters were spot on.”
28. Simon's Coffee House
198 reviewsClosed Now
Soups, American$$ - $$$Menu
1.3 mi
Sarasota
“My wife had the salad with salmon which...”
“... food, paninis, vegan and veg burger...”
29. Piccolo Italian Market & Deli
208 reviewsClosed Now
Specialty Food Market, Italian$Menu
2.2 mi
Sarasota
“Delicious, Fresh Subs and Sandwiches”
“... I sometimes just get a slice of pizza.”
30. 3.14 Pi Craft Beer
266 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, American$$ - $$$
“Best greek salad!”
“Pizza and wings excellent”
Sponsored
Marina Jack
1,693 reviewsClosed Now
American, Bar$$ - $$$Menu
4.5 mi
Sarasota
“We were celebrating a birthday and they brought out a Key Lime pie slice that...”
“... over garlic spinach, the braised lamb special and chicken pesto pasta.”
$USD
United States

This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu.