We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Pizza Places in Long Island

Filter and search through restaurants with gift card offerings.
See restaurants with gift cards
View map
Map
Satellite
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
COVID-19
Shows restaurants actively taking safety measures like added sanitation procedures, mask-wearing guidelines, and more. Learn more at our Travel Safe hub.
Establishment Type
Show more
Restaurant features
Show more
Meals
Reservations
Price
Cuisine
Show more
Dishes
Show more
Dietary Restrictions
Good for
Show more
Sort by:
Highest Rating
We found great results, but some are outside Long Island. Showing results in neighboring cities.
Limit search to Long Island.
1. Remo's Brick Oven Pizza
468 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu
20.7 mi
Stamford
“Tasty pizza ready in 15 minutes on a wet...”
“Great Pizza!”
2. Colony Grill
302 reviewsOpen Now
Pizza$Menu
20.1 mi
Stamford
“Great pizza in Stamford”
“Best bar pizza”
3. Branchinelli's Pizza & Restaurant
268 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu
7.7 mi
Hauppauge
“One of Long Island's Best Slices”
“Consistently Great Pizza”
4. Salvatore's Coal Oven Pizzeria
161 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$
19.3 mi
Port Washington
“Amazing pizza, tastes just like home!”
“Best pizza around!”
5. Brick+Wood
181 reviewsClosed Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$
24.4 mi
Fairfield
“Authentic Delicious Amazing”
“Best pizza in CT!!!”
6. Umberto's
283 reviewsCloses in 23 min
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$
18.6 mi
New Hyde Park
“Both were outstanding but I prefer the plain, quintessential NY pizza.”
“The margherita pizza was perfectly prepared & delicious.”
7. 1943 Pizza Bar
122 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$
55.6 mi
Greenport
“Still number 1 for pizza and more”
“Perfect Pizza”
8. Little Vincent's Pizza
223 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, Pizza$
6.8 mi
Huntington
“Hungry 4 Pizza 🍕”
“Late Night Slices 🍕”
9. Coals
111 reviewsOpen Now
Bar, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu
21.9 mi
Port Chester
“Excellent, unique pizza - it’s grilled.”
“Best pizza and beers”
10. La Piazza
223 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$
6.6 mi
Plainview
“Affordable good Italian”
“Consistently Good”
11. Sorrento's
90 reviewsClosed Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$
22.5 mi
Long Beach
“ITALY in Long Beach NY!”
“Largest small pizza in the world”
12. Sam's Restaurant
116 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu
61.6 mi
East Hampton
“Best Pizza on the East End. Still.”
“An East Hampton institution”
13. Colosseo Pizza
144 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, Pizza$
17.8 mi
Port Jefferson Station
“Excellent Sicilian Pizza!”
“BEST PIZZA.... period! No better anywere.”
14. Pizza Village
287 reviewsCloses in 23 min
Italian, Pizza$
74.8 mi
Montauk
“Cannoli”
“Quick bite to eat”
15. Sal's Pizzeria
194 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, Pizza$Menu
23.2 mi
Mamaroneck
“Opened in 1964- that says something”
“Not just pizza”
16. Umberto's Pizzeria and Restaurant
94 reviewsCloses in 23 min
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu
13.1 mi
Bellmore
“Great Pizza !”
“I like”
17. Gino's Restaurant and Pizzeria
133 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu
22.2 mi
Long Beach
“Proper slice of new york pizza”
“Came for two slices”
18. Scotto's Pork Store
85 reviewsClosed Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu
43.2 mi
Hampton Bays
“Great pizza and Italian take out”
“Good Eats!”
19. La Parmigiana Italian Restaurant
227 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu
50.3 mi
Southampton
“The pizza was LOADED and 1 piece filled...”
“Very Good Pizza”
20. Phil's Pizza
134 reviewsCloses in 23 min
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$
10.1 mi
Massapequa
“Slice”
“Pizza”
21. Villa Milano
89 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$
18.6 mi
Manhasset
“Great Food”
“Pizzeria serving up authentic Italian...”
22. Romanacci
96 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$
22.8 mi
Norwalk
“THE BEST PIZZA IN ALL OF WESTPORT”
“Fine Italian with a Twist”
23. Alitalia Pizzeria and Restaurant
80 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu
7.7 mi
West Babylon
“Indoor and outside seating”
“Fabulous pizza on Long Island”
24. Vulcano081
49 reviews
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$
18.6 mi
Rockville Centre
“Lisa trip to NY”
“More to Love Than Just Great Pizza”
25. Gino's Pizza
54 reviewsOpen Now
Quick Bites, Italian$$ - $$$
12.6 mi
Lake Ronkonkoma
“Another Outstanding Experience!”
“Looked and looked”
26. Saverio's Authentic Pizza Napoletana
31 reviewsClosed Now
Italian, Pizza$
9.1 mi
Massapequa
“Amazing in Every Aspect”
“Nice Family Run Store with Pizza better...”
27. Umberto's Restaurant & Pizzeria
100 reviewsOpen Now
Italian, Pizza$$ - $$$Menu
11.2 mi
Wantagh
“It is the best white pizza with ricotta, mozzarella , & basil.”
“good price, great grandma pizza, worth the trouble finding parking in the lot...”
28. Brunetti Pizza
59 reviewsClosed Now
Pizza, Italian$$ - $$$Menu
36.5 mi
Westhampton Beach
“The best wood fired pizza!”
“WHB pizza”
29. Ciro's Pizza
45 reviewsOpen Now
Quick Bites, Pizza$
8.1 mi
Smithtown
“Great Pizza”
“One of the Best Pizzerias ion Long Island”
30. Savor Healthy Pizza
68 reviewsClosed Now
Pizza, Italian$$ - $$$Menu
24.7 mi
Norwalk
“Rex and Val are wonderful very attentive”
“Discovered it on my birthday just after...”
© 2021 TripAdvisor LLC All rights reserved.
Terms of UsePrivacy and Cookies StatementSite MapHow the site works

This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu.