I learned that pistacchio is pronounced like Pinocchio - I will return to La Maddalena just to try this place again. Genuinely lovely service as well. Thank you for making a happy evening even happier, La Finestrellla! 😘

This place had a wide assortment of flavors and especially Tiramisu and Pistachio were very accurate and desirable and I would surely go back. I have all sorts of Gelato around the world, and this one is making a sure attempt to be the best.

According to my kids - who prize themselves on their ice-cream knowledge(!) - this place sells the BEST ice-cream in the WORLD! Downside is lots of people try to push in - you have to be quite forceful to not lose your place - but...More

Just awesome gelato. Great range of flavours. All 4 the family had were just fantastic. Very reasonable prices.

The ice cream here is complete, perfect taste, balanced sweetness. The service is fast. Flavors are a lot but I recommend "fior di latte" and "Nucciola". We've been sitting for five days and every night we serve ice cream after dinner!

Simply the best gelato we had over 11 days in Sardinia. Very good price, a lot of options and a very friendly staff that patiently explain everything about the gelatos.

I have stayed three days in La Maddalena and all days I have tried this ice cream. It was for sure the best ice cream I have ever had, it's a must have experience. I would definitely recommend fragola flavor.