I was on a trip from Chicago and I wanted to try a pizza like Pequod's Pizza so my wife and I went to Windy City Pie. WOW! It was better than Chicago's Pequod's Pizza. Pizza has been a big part of my life. I've...tried every type of pizza in Chicago over the years and there is always room for more great pizza. This is a new great one. We order online. That made getting our pizza easy when we got to Phinney. Cool space. Love the eclectic environment. Neat bar and drinks. Check out the artwork. But it's the food and the friendly staff that make this place great. It is the food that is the star of this evening. We had the Meatza. The crust was crisp especially the carmelized cheese edge. It may look burnt to those who don't understand what they are getting but don't overlook that delicious part of the pizza. The sauce is a perfectly tangy and sweet combination. The homemade sausage was delicious. The bacon and pepperoni are equally balanced with the other ingredients. The cheese works as a great counterpoint to the sauce and the other in tasty fresh parts of this masterpiece. This pizza is an indulgence that is worth the calories and carbs. Go for it. If you're worried about your diet they have other great options. My wife had the All Kale Caesar! salad. She loved the freshness, the switch of kale for the romaine lettuce and taste overall with a smaller serving of pizza which left more for me. This place is busy, order online, but be patient. Enjoy your night at this unique place.More

Certainly not your traditional regular crust pizza by far. We tried the 'Meatza' ... liked the thick crust as it held up well to the very very chunky tomato sauce, which was the biggest surprise for us. Toppings were quite good. Definitely feeds more than...just two people. Glad we tried it at least once. Fortunantely we had access to the Club Lounge at our hotel where we could obtain some cutlery as it arrives unsliced, which is noted on their website … after seeing the pizza, it is understable now why you have to slice it yourself.More

With great anticipation, I took my first bite of the Windycity pizza. I used to travel to Chicago for work and would look forward to my trips for the deep dish pizza there. I was a huge fan of Uno's, Lou Manati's, Giordano's and Gino's...East. I'm always on the look out for great deep dish. Seattle has had a number of such places come and go. The old Chicago's by the Key Arena (coliseum) was very good, Testa Rosa and Kylies-excellent are now gone. Currently Delfino's and Patxi turn out a nice pie. I make a pretty decent deep dish too. Getting back to my Windycity pie, it was very good, a nice flavorful sauce, ample toppings, nice spicy sausage, generous amount of cheese. Their signature burn cheese crust edge was very good, but the flavor and texture of the non edge portion failed to impress me. I was looking for something with a bit more crunch (Ginos) or a flakeier style (Patxi, Kylies) not the soft bread like texture that this had. Still this is a very good pie to try. Staff and service were excellent. Be prepared for a wait.More

Did take out--the instructions are a bit confusing, but the pizza pie was really tasty. This place is a 5 in Seattle but a 4 in New York. I am from New York so I have a pizza snub and I can say this place...has solid pizza. The sauce is good which is the most important part. I've been to Pagliacci's which is crap and Big Mario's which is alright. This place is better. They do not have dine in yet so do not show up unannounced. Call first.More

Have visited three times and each time we had a crazy-good pie. Their Classic is just that and the one with meatballs is out of this world. Can't wait to go back and try some others and craft our own. Great staff.

We stopped in here for a lunch meal of delicious Chicago deep dish style pizza and were totally impressed! If you want an ACTUAL authenticity to your deep dish pizza as opposed to just having more bread (like the knock offs) then try Windy City...because it is perfect! We tried the Meatza and it was so tasty and totally impossible to finish for just us two people and we can really eat!More

parking is tough, shared building with bar, ordered 8 slices to go. Too thick, not much taste. Demanded father remove 4 year old child from building.