Fresh bagels are top notch. The breakfast bagel sandwich is made to perfection. Quality is excellent.
11 - 20 of 47 reviews
Very very good bagels here. Also good sandwiches. The ambiance needs more yelling for it to be more like a NYC deli. But this far from New York, there's not much you can do. The eats are good! That's what counts.
Which is exactly what you want in a bagel! Also, for them to be boiled then baked. With a generous schmear. Which Gotham also does! Wow! It's almost like a bite of New York in Madison Wisconsin!
When ever we are in Madison we make it a point to visit this bagel shop. The variety is unparalleled and they use local where they can. I have never had a bad bagel there so I don't understand the negative reviews. I will continue...More
Quality of food, service, and cleanliness steadily declining. Never again after today. Food is clinging to two stars with the rest at one star. Ordered a couple of sandwiches to go. They placed them in baskets with the pickles and chips. I nicely stated it...More
I have tried all of the other bagel places in town and none of them come close to the quality of Gotham Bagels. They have an amazing lox bagel which is my go to but I have tried many others and they are all delicious....More
Gotham seriously serves the best bagels outside of NY. I'd even say they're better than some bagel places on Long Island. These are real bagels, not the nonsense you get at the bagel chains (Einstein, Panera, Etc.). They are hard on the outside and chewy...More
When Gotham opened several years ago, I was wowed by the wonderful New York style bagels. They were so tasty with just the right "chew." I also really loved their sandwiches and fresh squeezed grapefruit juice. But lately, I've been disappointed. I ordered many dozen...More
Stopped by this shop while visiting the Capitol and friends in Downtown. Got to meet the Owner Joe, who is very nice and a hard worker. He took the time to pose for a photo with us and a rack of his tasty bagels. Cool...More
We stopped by Gotham Bagels on the way to the Children's Museum with our 4 year old grandson. My wife and I shared a corned beef sandwich (very good) , and the kid had a bagel and a side of spicy Italian sausage. Surprisingly, he...More