We found this gem through TripAdvisor and very lucky to get a table for same day with an hour in advance reservation request by calling the restaurant. From the first moment we felt the very positive vibe & energy of the place. Everyone was so...friendly & helpful. Maria (the chef) came to our table twice and we had a nice chat about the foods. I asked for test of different wines and after the forth one we picked ours. Then we started our dinner with awesome basket of breads with very delicious mix of feta cheese & yoghurt. Without any request, our server refilled the basket twice! We tried four different kind of soups and four different kinds of main courses which all were amazing. At the end, they surprised us with yoghurt & baghlava dessert which was on the house. It was a dinner experience which I am sure my family will remember as a highlight of our trip to NY. Definitely we will be back here.More

My husband is Greek-American. We were visiting New York City from out-of-state and tried this restaurant for the first time. We were very impressed with the service and menu. The dishes were delicious and authentic. A special treat was meeting Maria, the owner. She was...greeting all the guests. We had a lovely meal with all our favorite Greek dishes. I highly recommend it!More

The moment you step into Loi, you feel like family…. from Alex’s warm greeting at the entrance (and authentic recommendations for food and drink), the attentive staff (thank you Victor!!) to Maria Loi’s genuine coversation and visit to our table… the food, company, and mastiha...is unforgettable. When does Loi close? When you are finished… like an intimate dinner party with lifelong friends. We will come again and cannot wait for our next visit. We don’t have a Greek restaurant is Hilo, Hawaii… just saying!!! Mahalo nui loa and see you again! xoxoMore

This restaurant came recommended from a colleague who knows the city. I was lucky enough to call and talk to Alex who happily worked us in the same day. From the moment we walked in, to the meal and after dinner drinks, we were pleasantly...surprised at every turn. Victor was an attentive server who accommodated our every need. Alex came to check on us several times and offered his expert opinion on the drink selection. Both he and Maria shared their stories and time with our group, having never met us before. I could not recommend Loi’s any higher. Do not miss this gem.More

From my phone call early Friday afternoon to the second we left the experience was warm, inviting, splendid! Nicole welcomed us with an incredible of sense of humor and kindness. The food was truly outstanding! Bone marrow soup, grilled octopus and two fish entrees. Plus...coffee and multiple desserts! Can’t wait to go back!!More

We were away for couple of years and we were most happy to discover that nothing changed at the best Greek gourmet restaurant that you can find. Same meticulous attention to food, wine, water, service, every part of the experience. The best Greek wines (and...they are happy to guide you if you not familiar), water from the Carpathian mountains. And every bite was delectable and entertaining.More

All of the dishes forour group, including those gratis, were substandard. Any good Greek diner serves better food. Please note large number of reviews by reviewers with just 1 or 2 or 3 reviews in their history, and come to your own conclusions.

This restaurant has a great reputation, because of its star chef, Maria Loi, but it deserves it. It was more modest than I had imagined, but it was elegantly appointed, and the food and service was delightful and impeccable. Ms. Loi greeted us and exchanged...advice (on the delicious olive oil), which did add to the pleasure of our dining experience. As did the yogurt and honey!More

I had dinner at Loi with friends & we had a great time. Alex greeted us warmly, and took us to our table and presented a wine and cocktail list.. My server Alvin greeted us promptly and took our drink and water order. Our Food...was OUT OF THIS WORLD . We did everything family style. The Chef Maria Loi came to speak with us and that was a treat. We Will Be Back!!More

Incredible food quality and preparation. Chef Loi really knows what she is doing. Wine selecttion amazing, Branzino straight from Greece - wow!!!! the Octopus grilled - insanely fantastic!!!!! Salads incredible!! The desserts,DELICIOUS . Service perfect. I could eat here every night. You will love it...too.More

Thank you Alex (Manager) for always taking care of us every time we visit. It feels like home. And the branzino is on point. Ryan Seacrest is correct!!

We met Maria walking to the Plaza hotel one night. From the moment we met her she was so friendly and nice. Her warm smile and kindness made us feel so welcomed to NYC and her restaurant. We then dined in her restaurant- the warm,...friendly atmosphere was perfect. The food was amazing. We all loved it even our children who are picky eaters ate their food and enjoyed it. Great dining experience for our family. We definitely will be back!More