Good sherpards pie if missing home food. Friendly staff and if Irish pretty good chance of been served all night
111 - 120 of 592 reviews
Except for some photos on the walls there is really nothing that reminds or HIMYM, it looks like any other pub/bar. It is a nice place to hang out but absolutely overprized, the food - most of us had a McGees burger - was really...More
The staff is friendly and we had fun as we are HIMYM fans. The food was also good but I think a bit pricey for what it is. Good location, not too far from Times Square.
We really enjoyed the atmosphere in this pub. I had a turkey burger, it was eh-okay, had better. The service was good. All in all a good place to hang out. No complaints
Just by inspiring the pub in HIMYM it deserves five points! Great pub, good beers and drinks, great environment and music. Come here every time you're in NY!
Went on a Wednesday afternoon so had no trouble getting a table. Food was good - nothing unusual or amazing - just good. There was lots of HIMYM pictures around (we are big fans but ended up at this place completely unintentionally). Would I go...More
Popped in having walked what seemed all day for a bite to eat before bed. Bar was fairly busy with parties and other diners. Drink service was immediate but having ordered food it took near on 45-50 minutes to come. Having wanted a quick pit...More
Found this pub by accident after wandering around trying to find somewhere to eat. Very glad we did. Great food at reasonable princes and great bar staff. Turned out to be a great night.
ducked in for warm food and cold beer on a rainy night. McGee's Ale was excellent. Fish and chips good. Service ok. Neighbors on either table side ordered more Irish fare which looked delish...shepherd's pie; chicken pot pie looked awesome. Had lava cake and coffee...More
I visited McGee's at my first night in NYC. I knew that pub was inspiration for How I met your mother tv serial which I am a big fan and this pub was on my "to do list" for New York trip. I went there...More