Great value!! Very well situated in the hustle and bustle of Little Italy. Some fantastic conversations with the staff. Would recommend

Great restaurant near the high line serving lunch and dinner. We o my had lunch but the food and service was excellent, good quality of food and drinks. Well Done!!!!!

I had the most amazing beef lasagna at this restaurant. The lasagna came with a yummy salad, too. The staff and the ambiance were fantastic. Restaurants in this neighborhood are pricey, but not this one. You should definitely try it if you are in town.

We met Sam, the host in front of the restaurant. His hospitable greeting set the tone to our enjoyable experience with the entire staff at Il Picolo Bufalo! Our waitress Andrea was very attentive in servicing us. The other staff members who went out of...their way to accommodate us were Sam, Raquel & Pedro who had ensured the pizzas were cooked to perfection, & they were!). When we thought that it couldn't get better than this, the owner, Alex engaged in a friendly & welcoming conversation with us and offered us dessert on the house! It's no wonder the staff had such excellence in their service, it trickles down from their main boss! We will most definitely recommend Il Piccolo Bufalo to friends & families! With sincere appreciation, Lorie & Andrew from the Upper East - ManhattanMore

Joey is the best of the best and the food is delicious!!! Highly recommend! We’re here for 4 days and we’ll be back before we leave! Thanks Joey!!

Joey was a phenomenal, funny host that treated us very well. The food was great and the vibe was fun. Will come back very soon

service and food was amazing!!! definitely will come again!!!! i loved every part of this place and was a great place to come!

Fantastic. Great atmosphere. Had the “Doc” Margherita pizza. Absolutely fantastic. Pizza was great. I’m sure the rest of the menu is just as good. Do yourself a favor and stop here if your in Little Italy.

Very good Italian food nice restaurant friendly atmosphere, I would recommend this restaurant to anyone that likes Italian food while in New York

This guy Joey is the best he hooked me tf up. Highly recommend. He's also helped me pick out a chain in the tourist trap near by.

Employees make you feel at home and have a warm welcoming experience. Love joe!! Everything taste great!

As an Italian… not Italian food. Everything but fresh ingredients… We went up & down the road trying to figure out where should be go in and I screwed up… first, not even one of the employees was close to an Italian ancestor… I think...this is the only one “Italian restaurant” without any Italian food. Pizza, antipasto, pasta all wrong ingredients and the substitutes, they didn’t even match… And, as you can see in the pictures… what the hell is having stuffed buffaloes all around? Small pieces of the fabric were flying around and landing on customers plates, that was really disgusting… seriously, don’t even step into this placeMore