We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
New York City

One if by Land, Two if by Sea

Reserve a Table
Fri, 1/17
8:00 PM

Ratings and reviews

Certificate of Excellence2016 - 2019 Winner

Mentioned in


$80 - $150

Location and contact

Improve this listing


Three course prix fixe 90
Long Island Fluke Tartare
Goldbar squash, sicilian pistachio, basil
Roasted Corn Risotto
Jalapeño, mint, manchego, Faicco's bacon
Lobster Cocktail
Yuzu aioli, avocado, marble potato
Wild Mushroom Pappardelle
Chanterelles, maitake, Castelmagno
Spiced Beef Tartare
Ginger, black plum, bonito aioli
Roasted Pear Salad
Belgian endive,'trail mix', valdeon blue cheese
Cured Arctic Char
Crème fraîche, tarragon, trout roe
Foie Gras Torchon
Granny smith apple, chestnut, brioche
Shellfish Custard
Mussels, shrimp, Jerusalem artichoke
Seared Maine Scallops
Butternut squash, capers, pumpkin seeds
Pan Roasted Dayboat Cod
Elements of new england clam chowder
Seared Scottish Salmon
Brussels sprouts, pistachio, shitake vinaigrette
Wild Black Bass
Carrot ginger escabeche, roasted autumn vegetables
Seared NY Strip
Sauce soubise, cucumber, watercress pesto, grits
Aged Eberly Guinea Hen
In‎ the style of coq au vin, celeriac potato purèe
Ricotta Gnudi
Cipollini onion, gruyère, arugula
Tasting of Long Island Duck
Trevisiano,‎ turnip, chocolate orange jus
Maine Lobster Bake
Steamers, connecticut corn, red bliss potatoes
Duo of Eden Farms Pork
Braised‎ cabbage, gremolata, beet, bread pudding
Beef Wellington
Asparagus, potato croquette, sauce bordelaise
Tasting of Chocolate
Varying degrees of cocoa
Liege Waffle
Carmelized white chocolate, maple custard, toffee
Red Velvet
Lemon‎ grass panna cotta, black sesame genoise
Spiced Pumpkin Soufflè
Cinnamon anglaise, bourbon molasses
Chocolate and Caramel Budino
Olive oil, almond cocoa crumble, cocoa nib
Daily Selection of Cheeses
Reviews (794)
Filter reviews
720 results
Traveler rating
Traveler type
Time of year
More languages
Traveler rating
Show reviews that mention
All reviews beef wellington scallops tasting menu souffle three course meal prix fixe salad steak romantic restaurant aaron burr barrow street special occasion new york romantic evening anniversary dinner our waiter valentine's day
Selected filters
Updating list...
1 - 10 of 720 reviews
Reviewed today via mobile

From the moment you walk through the doors the ambiance hit you in the face . This bar and restaurant has a touch of class with no snobbery , piano playing and cozy fire place adds to the atmosphere . The food and wine where...More

Date of visit: January 2020
Thank 985ste
Reviewed 4 weeks ago

One if by land has lost some of its romance it had twenty or thirty years ago because of some remodeling they have done to accommodate modern diners taste (expanded casual eating and bar area). However, still one of the best ambiances in the world...More

Date of visit: December 2019
1  Thank ericdetorres
Reviewed 4 weeks ago via mobile

For the money you pay at this restaurant I expect all staff to provide excellent service. The staff who ‘greet’ you need some training. The lack of a smile and a grunt of ‘happy anniversary’ is not good enough. It wasn’t that we’d just caught...More

Date of visit: December 2019
Thank suedQ4750UO
Reviewed December 2, 2019

Even though this restaurant is ranked Most Romantic in all of NY state, and it is gorgeous, the specialty cocktail we ordered was impossible to drink. Horrible, and at $44 for one glass of wine, mediocre, and a disgusting drink, it wasn’t too romantic.

Date of visit: December 2019
1  Thank Cindy W
Reviewed December 1, 2019

Located in the West village, this historic old carriage house is the place to go for special occasions (as Zagat's reports). As you enter you are greeted by the personable Maria and the piano bar. The latter being quite nice to just sit and have...More

Date of visit: November 2019
Thank TJM18701
Reviewed November 19, 2019

One if by Land lives up to expectations once again. I haven't been in the area of this NYC gem in a while. From the initial greeting through the front door through an after-dinner spirit on the bar, this restaurant was fantastic. Great service, great...More

Date of visit: October 2019
Thank Robbie11071242
Reviewed October 3, 2019 via mobile

Wanting to have Churchill’s favorite dish, stateside, I ordered the Beef Wellington, and was blown away. It’s hard to find since it’s not offered much, even in British restaurants and tea houses, I’ve been to and when sampled others have not compared to this. This...More

Date of visit: December 2018
Thank Stillpoint58
Reviewed October 2, 2019 via mobile

Romantic = Yes! Quality Food = Yes! Go here for that special occasion or if you desire a romantic setting with quality dining in NYC!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Date of visit: September 2019
Thank Mike D
Reviewed September 16, 2019

We were looking forward to a special evening here, we were “greeted’ by a woman who was talking on the phone and pointed vaguely in the direction of the bar. We opted for the tasting menu and matching wines. Whilst we made the effort in...More

Date of visit: September 2019
3  Thank Rebecca W
Reviewed September 3, 2019

Went here for the first time as we wanted to try one of the "most romantic" restaurants in NYC. Heard so many great things but not at all what we expected. First off dont know if air conditioning was broken or just off but it...More

Date of visit: August 2019
4  Thank Nick D
View more reviews
West Village
Stretching from Sixth Avenue to the Hudson River, the
West Village is one of the city’s most coveted
addresses. Full of trendy shops, historic taverns, and
cozy restaurants set amid 19th century architecture,
this neighborhood has a unique old-world feel. You
won’t find a more picturesque location in Manhattan.
Without the traditional city grid layout, it’s easy to
get lost here, but that’s part of the fun as you
Nearby HotelsSee all 510 nearby hotels
Washington Square Hotel
1,836 reviews
.21 miles away
The Marlton Hotel
765 reviews
.31 miles away
Courtyard New York Manhattan/SoHo
647 reviews
.38 miles away
Larchmont Hotel
505 reviews
.38 miles away
Nearby RestaurantsSee all 17,315 nearby restaurants
Boucherie West Village
1,075 reviews
.04 miles away
203 reviews
.04 miles away
Marie's Crisis
223 reviews
.04 miles away
Nearby AttractionsSee all nearby attractions
Foods of New York Tours
7,781 reviews
.02 miles away
New York Fun Tours
821 reviews
.08 miles away
Lower East Side Food Tour
67 reviews
.07 miles away
Fat Cat
80 reviews
.08 miles away
Questions & Answers
Ask a question
Charles S
December 11, 2018|
AnswerShow all 2 answers
Response from StarkGirl | Reviewed this property |
Nope, tip not included
June 26, 2018|
AnswerShow all 6 answers
Response from bp p | Reviewed this property |
Lisa T
October 8, 2017|
AnswerShow all 2 answers
Response from richardjwaksman | Reviewed this property |
Absolutely not. Any decent casual look is fine. The days of formal dress for restaurants in New York is almost extinct. Don't be a pig, but wear what you would wear to a Broadway show or to church or synagogue. We... More
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing