Updating Map... 1 - 10 of 195 reviews
We have not been to Abigael's in a number of years. There are many Kosher choices in NYC and we usually try new restaurants when we come to the city. The food was excellently served. Food was served promptly and efficiently. Food was tasty. Very...More
Wow! Many thanks for such a great review of Abigael’s! It’s wonderful to know that long-time customers still find us as good as ever! We’re delighted to know that you experienced so many of the things we take great pride in. We’re close to 25...More
Wonderful food, creative menu pairings, lovely ambiance, deep wine list and responsive waitstaff combine for a fabulous atmosphere.More
Thanks so much for the wonderful comments about your recent visit to Abigael’s! We’re delighted to know that you experienced so many of the things we take great pride in. While you were dining with us, hopefully you signed up for our Birthday & Rewards...More
In comparing this to other high end kosher places.. I think the presentation is superior while the portion size may be a bit small. The hangar steak was a bit small. A bit of a snafu as the medium steak came back kinda well done.......More
Woo hoo! Five Stars! Thanks for taking the time to post your thoughts about your recent visit to Abigael’s. It’s great to know that you enjoyed our extensive menus and wine list. Please know that we would have been happy to replace the steak that...More
10 of us arrived at 8:45 pm on Wednesday night, seated immediately, friendly and funny waiter not ruffled by our octogenarian’s attitude about eating at that hour of night. Delicious burgers (share the 1# burger with your friend) and French fries, nice salads, pareve ice...More
Wow! Many thanks for the great review of Abigael’s! It’s wonderful to know how much you enjoyed your evening and our awesome burgers… they’re boutique blended right on the premises with short rib, rib eye & brisket for a perfect balance of deliciousness! And thanks...More
One of the special appetizers was a duck taco --- I hope they put it on the regular menu but this, like their other menu items, are offered at very high prices (due to this being a Kosher restaurant). Both of our steaks were properly...More
Many thanks for taking the time to post your thoughts about your recent visit to Abigael’s. We’re delighted to know that you enjoyed it so much. That Duck Taco has been a hit all week! Please know that our prices are in line with other...More
Convenient to the neighborhood of my meeting and the train station, I asked my NYC based child to meet me for dinner here. We had a great meal - I had a rib steak, while she had something else and after a taste of my...More
We’re delighted to know that you had such a good visit to Abigael’s! Our steaks are always big winners, and the Brisket Egg Rolls are one our top sellers! Thanks for mentioning our great staff, and for taking the time to post your thoughts. Alison...More
After living most of my life in NY, but now living in TX. On a quick family trip, my wife was sick in the hotel so I decided to finally try Abigael’s. Heard the hype, figured ordering “to go” would be painless. After waiting for...More
Thanks for taking the time to post your thoughts. We have no doubt that you would have thoroughly enjoyed your meal, had you dined within the restaurant. As with most take-out, on a cold winter’s night, sometimes the food loses its heat which can alter...More
We simply love coming back to Abigail's again and again and again. The food never ceases to impress us, and the service is impeccable as always. We had Ozzie as our waiter, and he's always great. We were lucky enough to try some latkes (potato...More
Thank you so much for the wonderful review of Abigael’s! It is so great to know that long time customers keep coming back for more of our great food and service. And we’re delighted that you enjoyed the newer portions of our menu, too! Thanks...More
Except for needing to walk to the downstairs floor, this restaurant is everything it claims to be. We both opted for Salmon and it was cooked just right. Looking at the tables around us, all the entres looked well presented and the whole place smelled...More
We’re loving all those “GREATS”! Thanks for taking the time to post your thoughts about the great dinner you had at Abigael’s! For next time you visit, please know that we do have an elevator available ~ the entrance is in the main lobby of...More
The food was outstanding, service was excellent and knowledgeable waiters. I still did not understand why the Maitre said there was only 1 table for 3 at 8:15 and needed to reserve and while we where there eating, the restaurant did not fill up.More
So good to know that you enjoyed our food and service! We’re not sure why you got that incorrect info, but we will check into it with the staff. Thanks for taking the time to post about your visit to Abigael’s! We appreciate it! Alison...More
