We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Tripadvisor gives a Travelers’ Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travelers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor.
I visited this restaurant recently with my wife in honor of her birthday. We had Tim as our waiter. Tim is a very kind and warm individual, showing great hospitality toward his guests. He was able to attentively address our questions regarding the menu thoroughly...and accommodate our meal according to our preferences. He was able to relate to us on a personal level by providing his own honest recommendations regarding the menu. Our meal turned out to be above and beyond our expectations. Everything was so tasty and enjoyable. My wife and I are highly impressed by his excellent demeanor and friendly personality. He would go out of his way to ask us how the food was throughout our meal, kindly providing us with any last minute touchups to the food's taste. With a pleasant smile on his face, he'd always make sure we were happy with everything. We highly endorse him and recommend him for all of Abigael's guests. Overall, we really enjoyed our meal at Abigael's and hope to come back again in the near future!More
Date of visit: February 2020
AlisonNathan, General Manager at Abigael's, responded to this reviewResponded March 3, 2020
Wow! Thanks so much for the terrific review of Abigael’s! It’s great to know that you and your wife enjoyed your visit with us. Thanks for the shout-out to our waiter Tim. He’s a real treasure! We shared your post with Tim and the rest...More
Upon arrival for a business lunch, I was held up for almost 10 (!) minutes by the host, who was having a lengthy conversation with a potential guest.
When I finally met my partner inside, we were let down by a server who was not...only unfriendly but also a complete amateur. Didn't know the ingredients of the food he was offering and came back from the kitchen with partial answers and an indifferent attitude.
The Sea Bass was tasty but the whole experience, uninviting.
Not what I had remembered from the past.More
Date of visit: February 2020
AlisonNathan, General Manager at Abigael's, responded to this reviewResponded February 26, 2020
We are so distressed to read of this unpleasant experience! We did try to figure out when your visit may have been, but were unable to do so, as it would have been an opportunity to review the proper protocol with the waiter. Your comments...More
We went recently with another couple who had never been. We all ordered steaks and each of us was very satisfied...the steaks were done just as we requested, they were tasty and the portion was huge. We took home the portion we couldn't eat and...had a second meal on the leftovers! Our waiter was fine and the place was not too noisy. As before it was pricey -- but it's a kosher restaurant so that is to be expected.More
Date of visit: February 2020
AlisonNathan, General Manager at Abigael's, responded to this reviewResponded February 18, 2020
Thanks so very much for the 5-Star review of Abigael’s! We’re delighted to know that you and your guests enjoyed it so much! We take great pride in our consistently good food & service. We appreciate you mentioning them. Hopefully you’re a member of the...More
This was a truly delicious meal. I'll grant you that the downstairs dining room could really use a fresh coat of paint, but ignoring that, the food was excellent. My husband does not keep kosher and even he was impressed. Our server was prompt and...attentive without making us feel rushed. I had the Carnivore's Delight which was truly a mountain of food and so tasty. I will be eating the leftovers for days. We had the brisket egg rolls for an appetizer which were amazing. Believe it or not, the most delicious thing I had was the tomato dipping sauce that came with our bread basket. I don't know what is was, but I could have eaten that all day! I have very fond memories of watching Jeff Nathan on PBS with my grandmother and this was such a treat to eat at his restautant!More
Date of visit: January 2020
AlisonNathan, General Manager at Abigael's, responded to this reviewResponded February 3, 2020
Thank you to your hubby! That’s always been one of the best compliments we could ever get… when a non-kosher guest is impressed with our food! We’re delighted that you enjoyed your meal and the service at Abigael’s. We recently upgraded the streetscape of the...More
One of my favorite kosher restaurants in Manhattan. They offer both sushi and "regular" entrees. Been going there for 10 years, never had a disappointing meal, lunch or dinner.More
Date of visit: August 2019
AlisonNathan, Owner at Abigael's, responded to this reviewResponded December 17, 2019
Thanks so much for the terrific review of Abigael’s! We’re so pleased to know that you’ve been enjoying us for so long. We have quite an eclectic menu, and the Sushi / Pan Asian selections have been a hit since we started them about 15...More
Atmosphere in lower level felt like event space in the basement of an older Sheraton. Food was ok - menu is absurdly eclectic. Sushi was ok, beef vegetable soup had something hard and fibrous in it - like a husk. The Tuscan white bean soup...was better. Small portions. If you need Kosher, there are probably worse places to go but if you don’t, there are an infinite number of much better places. Our server was great and perfectly attentive.More
Date of visit: November 2019
AlisonNathan, Guest Relations Manager at Abigael's, responded to this reviewResponded November 26, 2019
We were troubled to read the mediocre review of your recent visit with us. We usually get some really great comments about our food and varied menu. We’re a bi-level restaurant, with dining rooms at street and lower levels. The street level offers views of...More
Loved the location and the food was great. The atmosphere was great and the service was excellent. I enjoyed the entree as well as the main mealMore
Date of visit: October 2019
AlisonNathan, Guest Relations Manager at Abigael's, responded to this reviewResponded November 25, 2019
Wow! Thanks so much for the great review of Abigael’s! We so pleased to know that you enjoyed your visit so much. Thanks for taking the time to post your thoughts. Be sure to sign up for our Rewards Program the next time you dine...More
Everything was amazing from the food to the service to the overall feel of the place. We couldn’t have asked for anything more. The food was so fresh, artistic, and packed with flavor. All the wait staff where very helpful and personable, and the dining...area was well organized and tidy. We loved it and hope to go back in the future.More
Date of visit: September 2019
AlisonNathan, Guest Relations Manager at Abigael's, responded to this reviewResponded September 17, 2019
Thank you very much for the wonderful review of Abigael’s! We’re delighted to know that you enjoyed everything about your visit! We take great pride in our food, service and ambiance. To have you mention each of those so positively, is really gratifying! Thanks again...More
Remember this place from the past and this was the first time that I was truly impressed. Loved my steak!
Date of visit: June 2019
jeffnathan1, Owner at Abigael's, responded to this reviewResponded July 30, 2019
Thanks for returning to Abigael’s during your recent trip to New York. We’re so pleased that you enjoyed it! And thanks for taking the time to share your post.
Guest Services // Promotions
Response from AlisonNathan | Property representative |
Our noise level is quite low. The construction in the restaurant is over so everything is back to normal. We have 350 seats and the spacing between seats happens to be more then the norm. We also have private party... More
Our noise level is quite low. The construction in the restaurant is over so everything is back to normal. We have 350 seats and the spacing between seats happens to be more then the norm. We also have private party rooms ranging from 12 - 300 for your dining convenience.
Thanks for inquiring, if you need any other assistance please don't hesitate to contact us.