Certificate of Excellence
Updating Map...
Contributor
426 reviews
232 restaurant reviews
321 helpful votes
Gramercy tavern has a reputation of excellent food. We had lunch here (not in the fancy part of the restaurant). The food, slices of lamb on toasted bread with a small salad, was nice, but nothing to write home about. Dessert and coffee also nice, but again nothing spectacular. Service excellent!
Thank GothenburgProfessor
Report
Contributor
39 reviews
12 restaurant reviews
12 helpful votes
My wife and I celebrated our recent anniversary at the Gramercy Tavern.
Be warned that, as you can see from the reviews, it's a very popular choice amongst locals and visitors. As a result, one learning is get your reservation very early. We actually had a family friend use her connections with someone who knew the owner to get us...
More
Thank SteveC_ATx
Report
Contributor
213 reviews
94 restaurant reviews
162 helpful votes
I try to come to GT when I am in town and it never has disappointed me over the years. Servers go out of their way to make you have a warm and memorable experience. Being a fan of the tavern area, I enjoy the energy of the bar and the front area of the restaurant. My grilled lamb with...
More
Thank Adventure Diva
Report
Contributor
290 reviews
219 restaurant reviews
61 helpful votes
We went for special occasion, and have been before. The room is beautiful and we were seated in back and a quiet table as requested. There are various options on the menu and husband being vegan chose the all vegetable tasting menu. Accommodations were made for him although he specificed no hard cheese with animal rennet and they did serve...
More
Thank shozgirl
Report
Contributor
10 reviews
4 restaurant reviews
The Arctic Char appetizer dish which is comprised of both cured and smoked varieties, along with cucumbers and black rice is a wonderful and zesty medley. The tavern atmosphere is easy and casual and the dining area appears distinctive and refined. All accolades are well deserved. Highly recommend to anyone who appreciates fine wine and cuisine.
Thank jco2012
Report
1 review
We visited the Gramercy Tavern on a Friday evening in August. We were told that there was a wait of 1 hour however this turned into an actual 2 hour wait. This would have been fine had the food been outstanding however we chose from the set menu and the main courses were both totally forgettable ! One was pork...
More
Thank ph244
Report
Contributor
25 reviews
11 restaurant reviews
7 helpful votes
We had the tasting menu for dinner with paired wines, both were excellent with great information from the knowledgeable and enthusiastic staff. Yes it's expensive, but the overall quality and attention to detail cannot be faulted.
Thank CrookeGirl
Report
Contributor
75 reviews
53 restaurant reviews
66 helpful votes
When I was in NYC 2 years ago, I went to the Gramercy Tavern on a lark. Loved it. I was lucky enough to see Hamilton last Saturday. Afterwards, we headed over to Gramercy.
The food! The service! The beautiful art on the walls! Once again, this is my favorite place in NYC. Whatever you order will be beautifully prepared....
More
1
Thank kaysandler
Report
Reviewed May 23, 2014
2 reviews Gramercy Tavern never disappoints. I love the vibe. The servers are attentive and friendly. The food is always wonderful.
Thank Windsor Y
Report
Contributor
39 reviews
19 restaurant reviews
29 helpful votes
We ate here for my husbands 50th birthday. We had the 6 course taster menu and a bottle of wine the bill was $453 for the two of us. Nice food, nice atmosphere. Staff very attentive. A special treat.
Thank tidgipud
Report
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Listing
Problem with this question?
Problem with this question?
Problem with this question?
See all questions (15)
Neighborhood Profile
Searching for available times... 
